![]() ![]() In terms of visuals, Chuang had prominent names like Daniel Zhou, Wu Yuheng, Lelush, or Gan Wangxing while YWY had Tony Yu, Kingston, and Chang Huasen.Ĭhuang was more diverse in terms of nationalities as well as background stories. Meanwhile, YWY’s dance line – Liu Jun, Kachine, Luo Zizhou – and vocal line – Xu Ziwei, Wei Hongyu – were just as powerful. Chuang had outstanding dancers like Santa and Riki as well as great vocalists like Mika and Jing Long. The gap between both shows was insignificant in terms of trainees’ quality. (Personally, I wouldn’t recommend watching YWY 1&3 and CHUANG 2020 because in my opinion those seasons were a mess but it’s still up to you)Īnyways, that ends my super long wall of text.– Mentors: Zhou Shen, Ning Jing, Amber LiuĬhinese, Japanese, Korean, American, Russian, ThaiĬhinese, Chinese American, Chinese Canadian, Japanese, Taiwanese No questions asked this subreddit is a result of this show’s greatness despite the controversies.Īnd of course Idol Producer but you already watched it before CHUANG 2021 (this year’s international season) This season is my favorite out of all the seasons, they have everything! Good trainees, good mentors, stellar performances and great variety! However, the sets and costumes CHUANG provides is definitely better than YWY.Īs for recommendations on what to watch on the shows you missed: They also make better Original songs than CHUANG. However, in terms of camerawork, YWY is absolutely stellar at that. If they have a good batch the performances are bound to be good. (However, I do believe the all the trainees are hardworking)Īs for performances, I think it is definitely up to the trainees. In which, I feel like they focus more on the persona and character their trainees represent I feel like the schedule of training in CHUANG is a bit more lax and caring for the personal well-being of the trainees. Especially, since YWY focuses more on the hardships or realities idols face in the industry. Like, YWY would really have cases of trainees collapsing from exhaustion or getting injuries. ![]() However, I do believe that when it comes to training, the training in YWY is a bit more rigorous than CHUANG. I do believe that CHUANG in terms of facilities are way more better than YWY (because YWY is just absolutely disgusting with providing the right facilities for their trainees, there are several trainees in YWY3 who went to the hospital because of this) Whereas for Youth With You it is a bit more difficult to see who’s rigged or who isn’t but I must say that YWY is a bit more apparent than CHUANG on who their picks are because you can definitely tell it right away because of the difference in screen-time they give to their faves and to those who aren’t Like in Chuang you definitely have a general consensus on who’s rigged or not. However, CHUANG is more obvious or apparent with it. There’s definitely some rigging on both sides SELECTION of the who wins or the final lineup ![]() I do think that the voting in CHUANG is a bit more open to international fans than Youth With You. I think they basically use the same style of voting as before using yoghurt to have more votes, however I think CHUANG uses a more inflated system in terms of voting (especially in the girl seasons) whereas, YWY uses a less inflated version. I made a comment before on this sub which compared the current seasons of CHUANG and Youth With You namely CHUANG 2021 and YWY3Ĭomparison of the first and second stages (P.S I made a separate post cuz this sub was left automoderated with no actual mods to check)Īs for their difference the comments here pretty much explained it. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |